City Council enforces $42,195 fine for destruction of Nashville Avenue home

The New Orleans City Council enforced a $42,195 fine this month for the destruction of a Nashville Avenue home that the owner blamed on bad weather, but that city officials attributed to the condition he had left the home in. Scott Wolfe Jr. told the City Council that he had just begun a legal, permitted renovation of his family’s home at 506 Nashville Avenue when a storm in late December 2015 caused it to collapse. “Severe weather which was documented by the New York Times and meteorologists caused the collapse of our home,” Wolfe said at the council’s Dec. 15 meeting. “It destroyed our home.”

Newman School to replace building on campus with new science center

The Isidore Newman School received permission from city officials to tear down and replace one of the buildings on its campus, and an Audubon Boulevard homeowner will be able to tear down a Cohn Street home to extend his backyard. The Newman school will be replacing the demolished building with a science center, Donald Fant of Woodward Design+Build told the Neighborhood Conservation District Advisory Committee on Oct. 17. Meanwhile, the vacant 1,260 house at 7001 Cohn Street — described as an “investment property” — will be removed to extend the fenced-in backyard of the owner, Audubon Boulevard homeowner Christopher Bruno, said his representative Peter Connick Jr. Bruno bought the home in September, and a handful of neighbors around the property sent letters of support for his plan to tear it down, according to documents included with the application. Neither request drew any opposition nor any discussion by the NCDAC members.

Demolition request withdrawn for Broadway Street home

The request to tear down a multi-unit home on Broadway Street was withdrawn Thursday following opposition from neighbors, City Council officials said. Property owner Caroline Wendt had sought to tear down the home at 1407 Broadway and replace it with new construction after discovering that renovations would be more costly than she expected, she told neighbors earlier this year. She had owned it since 1995 and rented it as a three-unit rental to students, but she found water intrusion and structural issues with the ground-floor units increasingly problematic, she said. None of the renovation options she considered were likely to be recovered in rents, she said, so she reluctantly decided upon demolition and new construction. “The advantage of new construction as a two-family property, without the cost of elevating the property, is financially feasible,” she wrote to neighbors in September.

Uptown, Carrollton historic oversight sails to City Council

A new oversight structure for historic homes in much of Uptown and Carrollton easily moved forward to the New Orleans City Council for a final decision on Tuesday, after the City Planning Commission swiftly voted in favor of recommendations that have been pending for most of the year. Demolitions through much of Uptown have long been governed by an agency now known as the Neighborhood Conservation District Advisory Committee, but Mayor Mitch Landrieu has recommended consolidating that entity with the Historic District Landmarks Commission, eliminating what was largely a duplication of services. In February, a study committee of residents appointed by Landrieu laid out the details of how they believed the new HDLC oversight should function:

The vast majority of Uptown and Carrollton should fall under the “partial” control of the HDLC, giving the commission scrutiny over demolition requests but nothing else. Property fronting St. Charles or South Carrollton avenues, however, would receive “full” control by the HDLC, so that any changes — demolition, construction or renovations — visible to the public would require HDLC approval.

Jean-Paul Villere: Shot calling

Tuesday morning I awoke abruptly just before 4 a.m. from a dream.  Convinced I was awake for the day, I decided to send a few emails.  While clacking out my correspondence in the dead silence of pre-dawn I heard in the not-too-far distance successive gunshots.  I thought it was about eight rounds.  Maybe it was seven.  But does it even matter how many there were?  I called 911.  They took my location, name, etc.  Then I went for a run.  And this is normal in New Orleans.  At least for now. The Big Easy life choices run the gamut.  Choosing to live here means keeping your wits about you and trying to avoid being in the wrong place at the wrong time.  Often it seems incidents like these shake out with a certain specificity, actions taking place between known parties.  But then there are numerous other examples of random.  So what do you do?  Live in fear?  Move away?  Stay?  Kvetch in your weekly online rant?  I’m not going to not live here, but I’m also not going to ignore our problems either. New Orleans exhibits a host of ailments.  Sometimes too daunting to even consider where to start.  Education is fine place for a foundation.  The woes of Katrina’s ravages did reboot the city’s school offerings at large.  And that’s huge.  We are a short 11 years after, and educationally we are light years ahead of where we likely would have been had 8/29 never happened.  New Orleans’ school systems were arguably beyond broken then, but the opportunities that have arisen since?  Those have yet to be measured. My point is we might expect to see the fruits of the efforts from this decade’s plus influx of educators in another 11 years; we have to.  I don’t think the party, though likely parties, responsible for the early morning gunfire I audibly witnessed had access to the same educational benefits young New Orleanians now have access to.  And that’s a weighty perspective.  Irksome only scratches the surface to the awful redefining of normalcy in the Crescent City.  But you can’t give up.  You just can’t. EPILOGUE: Last week while further clearing a blighted lot in my neighborhood, I happened upon a stoop perched man, crouched over, back turned just so, presumably trying to shoot heroin.  Fact: I clear needles from this lot all the time.  Shortly thereafter two young men stand watch over that nearest corner where they stay I guess, surveying the activity of the surrounding blocks.  Once they retire inside, moments later three little boys, likely no more than six years-old and dressed in matching school uniforms and backpacks, exit in queue and dutifully make their way toward the neighborhood’s school.

Demolition rejected for State Street home

A home on State Street in the university area will be spared demolition instead of being replaced by two other houses after review by the City Council last week. The owner of 2321 State Street — which property records show to be a company registered to real-estate agent Charlotte Dorion — had hoped to tear down the house and replace it with two homes, because it is on a double lot, said City Councilwoman Susan Guidry. That plan brought opposition from Erin Holmes of the Preservation Resource Center. “It is yet another inappropriately targeted Uptown property that is in perfect condition and needs to be reused,” Holmes told the City Council at their meeting Thursday. Guidry agreed, calling the house an “early 20th-century colonial revival structure, which is very much reflective of the character of this neighborhood.”

Jean-Paul Villere: How I spent my summer vacation

As summer’s sizzle dissipates over the coming weeks, the back-to-school throngs may muse on their most recent season away from academia, and some may even have it as their premiere assignment upon recommencement.  While I don’t really recall in my younger years a time when this was asked of my fertile student mind, my 42-year-old memory ain’t what she used to be.  So color me pseudo-nostalgically amused when my oldest had this very task put to her and she wrote about our family train trip to Chicago.  Which I totally dug too.  Except, and in honest reflection, my real takeaway for summer 2016?  Pecking away, hours over days and largely singlehandedly, at an overwhelmingly under-maintained vacant corner lot in my neighborhood. Bottom line: I snapped.  I couldn’t take it anymore.  I got all Network on this behemoth of overgrowth, harboring all the years of refuse, beer bottles, sodded styrofoam, spent syringes, and a seemingly endless collection of tossed tires and beyond repair furniture.  And oh the mattresses!  Oozing over sidewalks and lushly spilling into the streets.  One pauses to wonder albeit without gravity, “Isn’t the city going to do something about this?”  Then one recalls “No, this is New Orleans, where a month without a boil water advisory is like a gold star on your homework. Trash is our brand, sadly.”  And clearly the delinquent but titled property owner was not actively in the picture.  So, what to do?  Nothing?  I could no longer do nothing.  So I started. I rolled up early one May morning armed with hydration, sunscreen, a smattering of yard tools and volunteer garbage cans.  Weeds pulled, vines yanked, and repetitive flat shovel scrape and drag across the asphalt surface.  Looks aplenty from passersby, some trading morning pleasantries, most wondering “What that crazy white boy doing.”  The first day’s dent could hardly be described as such.  The results akin to one of those visual games on a kids paper restaurant menu where discerning the subtleties amounts to two burgers differentiated by one having a sesame seed bun and cheese and the other not.  They’re both still burgers, and I’d only just started undressing it. Every five to seven days or so I’d arise before sunup, cup of stovetop coffee down the gullet, and alit into dawn’s darkness wary of the leaching rays of the oncoming day.  Most days the neighborhood crackheads would make random if fleeting conversation with me, often along the lines of subtle discouragement but usually strung together indecipherable ramblings.  I developed a pleasant repartee with the mail carrier, sharing my goal of clearing the sidewalk for her by end of August.  Both of us were unsure of just how possible that might be, given the solo resource, myself.  Today is August 24th, so take note trusty timekeepers: the month ain’t over yet.

Guest column: Uptown historic district should oversee demolitions and new construction, but not minor renovations

By Sandra Stokes, president of the Louisiana Landmarks Society

The City Planning Commission is scheduled to discuss the creation of historic districts in Uptown and Carrollton at 1:30 p.m. Tuesday, Aug. 23, in the City Council chamber at City Hall. It has become all too familiar in historic neighborhoods – perfectly proportioned historic homes demolished for totally out-of-scale McMansions; harmonious streetscapes marred by inappropriate new construction; or additions that look like cancerous growths on what was a perfectly fine home. Louisiana Landmarks Society recognizes the advantages of local historic districts in maintaining scale and character in neighborhoods, while providing stability and predictability. At the same time, we also understand the concerns of residents that being subject to the jurisdiction of the Historic Landmarks District Commission (HDLC) might infringe upon their personal property rights.

Demolition requests deferred, denied on Nashville, Broadway and Peniston

Demolition requests for large homes on Nashville Avenue, Broadway Street and Peniston Street were all denied or deferred on Monday by city officials. The request at 704 Nashville Avenue was not technically for a full demolition, but for “alteration of the front facade to accommodate the addition of a second story to this single-family home,” according to city documents. That plan, however, came under opposition from the neighbors and from preservationists. “This is one of two historic houses that are identical in facade in this block,” wrote Jay Seastrunk, an architect and member of the Louisiana Landmarks Society. “They are unique structures which contribute to the overall scale and character of the neighborhood, and defacing one of them by adding a second-floor gallery and eliminating its steep-pitch gable roof would destroy the historic character and dramatically change the scale.”

Historic church on Jackson Avenue to be renovated into private home

The 143-year-old former church at 2517 Jackson Avenue is slated to become a private home with a swimming pool and gardens, following the approval of permission to demolish an old home next door. The plan was described to city officials at the July 18 meeting of the Neighborhood Conservation District Advisory Committee, where Crane Builders were requesting the demolition of a blighted home at 2509-11 Jackson Avenue. The owner was not named, but the property is registered to a company based in Aspen, Colo., property records show. “The owner also owns some adjacent properties, so this demolition request is associated with the grander plan, as it were, for subdivision of these several lots, which would include renovation of a historic church two lots down that was built in 1873,” said Beau Johnson of Crane Builders, representing the owner. “The subject building, we believe, was built in the ’50s, modified several times, blighted, in disrepair, and previously unoccupied except by a squatter.”